The sound distributed version control system

#265 Bikeshedding: Multihash

Closed on August 4, 2021
indo on January 14, 2021

Multihash is a standard for identifying hash functions. Pijul already does this using a non-standard identifiers and places them at the end of the hash, as that is more useful to end users. A hybrid approach would be to use the Multihash identifiers but concatenated at the end of the hash.

fabian on January 15, 2021

There is a multihash MIT licensed lib if anyone is interested: https://crates.io/crates/multihash

Personally, I don’t think this will add much more interoperation / future-proofing of the hashing mechanisms however it is a nice-to-have.

pmeunier on August 4, 2021

I’m trying to triage as many discussions as possible before moving to the beta.

This proposal is perfectly valid, but would completely break our current scheme, with few expected benefits. I don’t know if cryptographers expect current hashing schemes to break in the future, but our current scheme is more of a “future-proof” guarantee than a real interoperability thing. After I wrote Thrussh (an SSH crate in Rust), I’m also a bit skeptical about these interoperable crypto algorithms, since they always end up being superseded at some point, and may cause a lot of complexity and extra dependencies (I’m not saying this is necessarily the case here).

pmeunier closed this discussion on August 4, 2021